Eureka
Home Advertise Magazine Events Eureka TV Directory
  


Subscribe

Engineer or artist?
14/09/2008 Email to a friend   Comment on this article
Here’s a surprise: I recently read an article in the Daily Telegraph that annoyed me...

Here’s a surprise: I recently read an article in the Daily Telegraph that annoyed me.

It has to do with a recent collaboration project between a noted artist – Anish Kapoor – and a high profile engineer, namely Cecil Balmond of structural engineering firm Arup.

The two have got together to create a huge public sculpture called Temenos, which will stand in the old Tees Dock in Middlesbrough. The Telegraph makes much of the partnership between the two – calling their collaboration the work of an ‘enginartist’, in whom “engineering and aesthetic powers meet on equal terms”.

The article goes on to say that Kapoor has agreed to “share equal billing” with Balmond – much against the grain of artists, sculptors, architects and other professions that grab sole glory for work that is in fact a team effort.

As Balmond is quoted: “Engineering’s not sexy to talk about. The annoying thing is that engineers are supposed to be calculating machines, mathematically brilliant technocrats, but they’re denied creativity.”

He cites Brunel as the archetypal ‘engineer who creates’ – and bemoans the fact that the contribution of engineers is often “absorbed into the author’s credit”.

It struck me that the idea of ‘art meeting engineering’ is perfectly captured within the field of design engineering. People not familiar with the field often ask whether a design engineer is a designer or an engineer. I usually answer that they are both.

But further than that is the notion – held even by Balmond – that “engineers cannot create”. It’s true that a product designed for the mass market is not a one-off piece of art, but a carefully constructed engineering that is designed to a specific brief.

But to go from a blank sheet of paper to a manufacturable product is creation. Isn’t it?

 
Author
Lou Reade
 
 
Supporting Information
http://www.eurekamagazine.co.uk
 
This material is protected by Findlay Media copyright 2012.
See Terms and Conditions.
One-off usage is permitted but bulk copying is not.
For multiple copies contact the sales team.
 
Bookmark this article using:
 
Del.icio.us digg reddit Facebook StumbleUpon
 
 
Your comments / feedback
Do you have any comments or feedback on this article? Please contact us by filling in the form below.
NameHide name
Your Email Address
Comments
Send
Your comments/feedback may be edited prior to publishing. Not all entries will be published.
Terms and Conditions

To comment on news stories or blogs you need to complete our 60 second registration process. Once completed this then allows you to download any and all white papers, register for e-zines and access our detailed supplier directory for FREE.

If you are all ready a registered user then enter your e-mail address and login.

You will need to have logged in prior to entering your comments in the boxes provided.

Please enter your email address to login and gain free access to this site.
 
If you are using this site for the first time registration is quick and completely free.
 
Register Now - Register Now


Email Address :  

Remember Me: - If this box is ticked you will be automatically logged in when you return.

Important: To protect your privacy, do not select 'Remember Me' if other users have access to the computer you are using.

View Privacy Policy
 
Related Companies
eurekamagazine.co.uk
 
 
Related News
Dyson ceo urges government to give more support to manufacturing sector
 
Hargreaves review urges government to modernise IP law
 
UK Manufacturing hits 16-year high
 
Queen's Awards announced
 
3Dconnexions unveil 3D mouse
 
 
Related Technology
Cover story: Forward in reverse
 
Seeing the big picture
 
Innovatory challenges to get out of the recession
 
Talking to the experts - machine building special report
 
Innovation is the way forward