Eureka
Home Advertise Magazine Events Eureka TV Directory
  


Subscribe




Are we still talking about this?
07/04/2009 Email to a friend   Comment on this article
The argument for going to 3D from 2D packages still seems to be out there but it is somewhat less forceful than it was. Justin Cunningham reports

Are we still talking about this

It seems for the likes of Autodesk at least, it has begun to realise that for users still on 2D, some 60% of its customers, there is little chance of convincing them otherwise.

So what is stopping these users from moving over? Is it the change aspect that people are naturally fearful of, how it might affect processes and production, or does 2D do what many people want and they are not interested in all the fancy benefits that 3D is touted to bring?

"There is a lot of that," says Colin Watson, a business development director for Imass – a software solutions provider. "In many sectors, 2D drawings are the deliverables that trigger payment. It is based on presenting 2D drawings, not a 3D model.

"But also, there is a whole generation of people who can still read a 2D drawings. That doesn't exist so much anymore and the younger generation are use to using 3D models and 3D images. For them, seeing a 2D drawing sometimes doesn't mean a great deal."

For many companies, working in 2D gives them the solution they want. And in the present climate a move to 3D represents risk. Despite all the advances and effort by the CAD vendors to make the jump as straightforward and pain free as possible, it is still a daunting step.

As well as a different method of using and commanding the software to do what you want, designing in 3D is different on a conceptual level. In the 2D world, users have to be very precise about measurements and the way it is laid down as a drawing. But, in 3D, particularly with programs such as Autodesk's Inventor, much of that is conceptual design work, sketched in 3D. It then has the precision dimensions added once the overall form is correct.

"It changes the whole way working," says Watson. "That means a definitive need to train people."

For those that make the leap of faith, it does on the whole lead to productivity improvements. But this does take time and does not happen overnight. And in the current climate where many companies are reassessing productivity and costs on a month by month basis, this is simply not an option.

But 2D CAD is not the AutoCAD that many might remember, fresh out of 1985. Despite being a 2D package, it has moved on massively and various add-ons and modules mean that it is, in most respects, a state of the art piece of software. Autodesk has put large amounts of effort to get the 2D packages to interact well with 3D.

"If you're a 3D user on one of the mechanical applications like Inventor, these can produce 2D drawings automatically from the model," says Watson. "The work that Autodesk are doing is making that automatically generated 2D content much richer. That means when it is passed a 2D application user to finish off the detailing, less work is actually involved as most of it is done on the model.

At present, Imass is finding users who haven't yet made the investment in 3D are waiting until they feel more confident in there own situation and the companies financial position before making that decision.

But, interestingly, companies that have made the investment are increasingly going back and re-examining the software to try to make more use of it as they have found they are only using a very small percentage of what it can actually do.

"I do see that as our major role at the moment," says Watson. "Rather than finding companies that have a 2D process and then trying to migrate them across, which is a time consuming process. The new business side of it is slowing down, but there is still business to be had with existing customers. That is training them and making them aware of new functions and things like configuration management etc."

 
Author
Justin Cunningham
 
 
This material is protected by Findlay Media copyright 2012.
See Terms and Conditions.
One-off usage is permitted but bulk copying is not.
For multiple copies contact the sales team.
 
Bookmark this article using:
 
Del.icio.us digg reddit Facebook StumbleUpon
 
 
Your comments / feedback
Do you have any comments or feedback on this article? Please contact us by filling in the form below.
NameHide name
Your Email Address
Comments
Send
Your comments/feedback may be edited prior to publishing. Not all entries will be published.
Terms and Conditions

To comment on news stories or blogs you need to complete our 60 second registration process. Once completed this then allows you to download any and all white papers, register for e-zines and access our detailed supplier directory for FREE.

If you are all ready a registered user then enter your e-mail address and login.

You will need to have logged in prior to entering your comments in the boxes provided.

Please enter your email address to login and gain free access to this site.
 
If you are using this site for the first time registration is quick and completely free.
 
Register Now - Register Now


Email Address :  

Remember Me: - If this box is ticked you will be automatically logged in when you return.

Important: To protect your privacy, do not select 'Remember Me' if other users have access to the computer you are using.

View Privacy Policy
 
Related Companies
Autodesk Ltd
 
IMASS
 
 
Related News
Autodesk Q1 net up 14%
 
Autodesk software helps clean tech firm fuel ‘smart water’ networks
 
SolidWorks unveils eDrawings iPad app
 
3D printing technique to revolutionise healthcare industry?
 
Autodesk unveils ForceEffect Motion app
 
 
Related Technology
Seeing into the future: Eureka asks three CAD companies what they see as emerging technologies
 
Wiring simulation tool slashes lead times, lowers evaluation costs
 
Designing in 3D: How 3D printing is changing the way product design and development are taking place
 
Overcoming the issues associated with migrating CAD data
 
Cloud computing offers new possibilities to design engineers
 
 
Related Events
TCT Live 2012
 
 
Related Technology Spotlight
Award-Winning Gripple Uses PTC’s CAD & FEA Tools to Cut Design Time
 
System family prints multiple materials simultaneously
 
Prototyping makes its mark
 
Rapid manufacturing applied to human prosthetics
 
Paper prototyping makes a comeback
 
 
Related Blogs
Fascinating, but has anybody got a use for this?
 
 
Related Whitepapers
Prototyping Whitepaper: Why Physical and Digital Methods Are Complementary
 
How 3D Printing Works
 
A Better Way to Capture 3D Data
 
Buyer's Guide to Selecting a 3D Printer
 
Life in 3D - New Efficiencies in Rapid Colour 3D Modeling
 
 
Related Videos
Lighting Reality speed test video
 
Spelsberg els customised enclosures
 
Bloodhound project: 1050mph
 
A proof of concept with Microsoft and dezineforce
 
The Pro/Engineer from PTC